Format for e-mail

CFJ:	2753
Interest Index:	0
Statement:	If adopted, the effects of "Library of Senate" would be canceled by R1698 (Agora Is a Nomic).
Caller:	Pavitra
Judge:	comex
Judgement:	FALSE
Currently Eligible:	coppro, Murphy

---

History:

Called by Pavitra	2 Dec 2009 22:19:35 GMT
Assigned to comex	6 Dec 2009 22:40:41 GMT
Judged FALSE by comex	6 Dec 2009 22:47:02 GMT

---

Caller's Evidence:

(2 Dec 2009 22:19:35 GMT)

I submit the following proposal, II=1, AI=1, "Library of Senate":
{
Amend Rule 1750 (Read the Ruleset Week) by appending the paragraph:

      This rule is an Agoran National Treasure. All players SHOULD
      protect it from being amended or repealed.

}

---

Gratuitous Arguments by Tiger:

(2 Dec 2009 22:25:47 GMT)

It is possible to speculate about, but impossible to
reasonably determine, the extent to which all present and future
players would follow a hypothetical SHOULD. I would say INDETERMINED
or UNDECIDABLE depending on whatever those two mean (I always mix them
up).

---

Judge comex's Arguments:

(6 Dec 2009 22:47:02 GMT)

FALSE, per above.  (Anyway, I doubt that players would hesitate to
violate the SHOULD in that case.)