Format for e-mail
| CFJ: | 2750 |
| Interest Index: | 0 |
| Statement: | If the Chief Whip announced that 2 + 2 = 5, it would be legal to publicly agree. |
| Caller: | Murphy |
| |
| Judge: | ais523 |
| Judgement: | UNDETERMINED |
| |
| Currently Eligible: | coppro |
History:
| Called by Murphy | 29 Nov 2009 17:17:05 GMT |
| Assigned to ais523 | 29 Nov 2009 17:57:58 GMT |
| Judged UNDETERMINED by ais523 | 2 Dec 2009 21:46:31 GMT |
Caller's Arguments: | | (29 Nov 2009 17:17:05 GMT) |
The Chief Whip card is possessed by the Lost and Found
Department, a non-person. Is this sufficient to force a judgement
of UNDECIDABLE?
Judge ais523's Arguments: | | (2 Dec 2009 21:46:31 GMT) |
I judge CFJ 2750 UNDETERMINED. The way I parse the statement of the CFJ,
the conditional is only satisfied if the L&FD (the Chief Whip at the
time the CFJ was submitted) makes an announcement. Several rather
radical rule changes would be needed before that would be possible, and
it's impossible to guess what changes in Truthiness would or would not
be made at the same time. Therefore, there's insufficient evidence to
resolve the hypothetical.
