| CFJ |
Called by |
Statement |
Judgement |
| 2215 (pt) |
woggle |
BobTHJ created 11 crops in ais523's possession when e should have only created 9 [3 for harvesting 911, 6 for harvesting 869]. |
case open |
| 2214 (pt) |
ehird |
Wooble violated 2170 for claiming to be tusho (an old name of mine). |
case open |
| 2213 (pt) |
comex |
The Patent Title Scamster has been revoked from come. |
TRUE |
| 2212 (pt) |
Wooble |
An IRC channel is a forum. |
case open |
| 2211 (pt) |
root |
It is POSSIBLE to perform game actions via the #really-a-cow forum. |
case open |
| 2210 (pt) |
woggle |
The Law-abiding Partnership broke Rule 2148 by claiming to be the ambassador. |
case open |
| 2209 (pt) |
comex |
There exists at least one partnership that is a person. |
case open |
| 2208 (pt) |
comex |
The Law-abiding Partnership is a person. |
case open |
| 2207 (pt) |
comex |
I am Dvorak Herring. |
case open |
| 2206 (pt) |
ais523 |
I transferred at least 2 Chits to the PerlNomic Partnership today |
FALSE |
| 2205 (pt) |
ehird |
This CFJ was initiated or will be initiated at midnight, 1 July 2008. |
case open |
| 2204 (pt) |
ais523 |
At the end of the voting period of the Agoran Decision on whether to adopt proposal 5707, BobTHJ had 5 valid unretracted conditional votes that resolved to votes FOR that decision. |
FALSE |
| 2203 (pt) |
root |
root cast at least one unretracted vote of AGAINST on Proposal 5707. |
TRUE, appealed |
| 2202 (pt) |
Wooble |
Proposal 5707 is a democratic proposal. |
FALSE |
| 2201 (pt) |
Wooble |
The ratification of the Short Logical Ruleset CAN cause the text of a rule to change. |
TRUE |
| 2200 (pt) |
Ivan Hope |
This CFJ will exist one second from now. |
TRUE |
| 2199 (pt) |
Ivan Hope |
Including "From: root <root@normish.org>" in the email header constitutes a claim to be Ian Kelly (a.k.a. root). |
FALSE |
| 2198 (pt) |
root |
BobTHJ and root won the game on September 26, 2008 UTC. |
case open |
| 2197 (pt) |
ais523 |
The CotC CAN assign a judge to a CFJ initiated in the quoted message. |
FALSE |
| 2196 (pt) |
Wooble |
The nomic in which this CFJ is being judged is a foreign nomic. |
TRUE, appealed |
| 2195 (pt) |
ehird |
The computer by which I am sending this email is a nomic. |
FALSE |
| 2194 (pt) |
ais523 |
Phill has a White Ribbon. |
FALSE |
| 2193 (pt) |
Goethe |
tusho violated Rule 2170 by publishing a message purportedly from "phill" and registering as a player. |
GUILTY |
| 2192 (pt) |
ehird |
tusho has been a player at some point in time |
TRUE |
| 2191 (pt) |
ehird |
tusho is a player |
TRUE |
| 2190 (pt) |
ehird |
tusho is a person |
TRUE |
| 2189 (pt) |
ehird |
Phill is a player |
TRUE |
| 2188 (pt) |
ehird |
Phill is a first-class person |
TRUE |
| 2187 (pt) |
ehird |
Phill is a person |
TRUE |
| 2186 (pt) |
ehird |
Phill sent the message quoted (as evidence #1 - eir registration) |
TRUE |
| 2185 (pt) |
ehird |
I am tusho. |
TRUE |
| 2184 (pt) |
ehird |
I am Phill. |
TRUE |
| 2183 (pt) |
Sir Toby |
It is impossible to assign a judge to the CFJ allegedly initiated in the message sent by "agoran@live.com" on "Tue, 16 Sep 2008 20:16:23 +0000" (see evidence 1) without revealing some information regarding who did or did not send the message. |
TRUE |
| 2182 (pt) |
Sir Toby |
The message sent by "celestialcognition@gmail.com" on "Sat, 20 Sep 2008 22:21:09 -0500" (see evidence 1) was successful in initiating a CFJ. |
FALSE |
| 2181 (pt) |
root |
root broke Rule 2170 by making the statement "I am comex.". |
UNIMPUGNED |
| 2180 (pt) |
Hillary Rodham Clinton |
The message sent by "agoran@live.com" on "Mon, 15 Sep 2008 20:15:58 +0000" was successful in submitting a proposal. |
UNDETERMINED |
| 2179 (pt) |
Sir Toby |
The message sent by "agoran@live.com" on "Tue, 16 Sep 2008 20:16:23 +0000" (see evidence 1) was successful in initiating a CFJ. |
TRUE |
| 2178 (pt) |
ais523 |
If a non-pledge contract has no parties, it can be amended by unanimous consent of its parties. |
FALSE |
| 2177 (pt) |
Ivan Hope |
I am Mr. Elbow. |
FALSE |
| 2176 (pt) |
Ivan Hope |
Wolfram Blitzen is the owner of a Twin Sister. |
TRUE |
| 2175 (pt) |
Ivan Hope |
Mr. Elbow SHALL register as soon as possible. |
FALSE |
| 2174 (pt) |
Ivan Hope |
Ivan Hope CXXVII can act on behalf of Mr. Elbow by announcement |
TRUE |
| 2173 (pt) |
Ivan Hope |
Mr. Elbow is a person. |
TRUE |
| 2172 (pt) |
ais523 |
The Monster is a person |
TRUE |
| 2171 (pt) |
Sgeo |
If a person who is bound by an equity agreement fails to fulfill eir obligations to the agreement, and the judge attempts to act on eir behalf, but there are 3 or more objections to the attempt, the person who failed to fulfill eir obligations may be liable for a criminal punishment other than discharge. |
TRUE |
| 2170 (pt) |
ais523 |
There is a contract called The Agoran Civil Service. |
FALSE |
| 2169 (pt) |
Ivan Hope |
If two persons agreed to Normish, it would become a contract. |
FALSE |
| 2168 (pt) |
Ivan Hope |
Normish is a nomic. |
TRUE |
| 2167 (pt) |
ais523 |
ais523 is the Monsterkeepor. |
case open |
| 2166 (pt) |
Goethe |
This is a CFJ. |
FALSE |
| 2165 (pt) |
comex |
Attributes of a person such as whether e is biological, wearing a hat, the same as another person, etc. can be ratified. |
UNDETERMINED |
| 2164 (pt) |
Hillary Rodham Clinton |
I submitted a proposal in my recent post |
UNDETERMINED |
| 2163 (pt) |
comex |
The text of a proposal cannot have any effect whatsoever on whether the proposal takes effect, except by influencing votes on the proposal, and as explictly stated by the Rules. |
TRUE |
| 2162 (pt) |
root |
A proposal that takes retroactive effect does so by modifying the gamestate of the present, not by altering events in the past. |
TRUE |
| 2161 (pt) |
root |
If Rule 1742 is upmutated to power 2, and the /dev/null contract continues to have no parties, it will remain a contract. |
TRUE |
| 2160 (pt) |
root |
The /dev/null contract has at least one party. |
OVERRULE / FALSE |
| 2159 (pt) |
root |
/dev/null is a contract. |
TRUE |
| 2158 (pt) |
comex |
Goethe pledged to lead / an effort to grant title / but no new Bard yet. |
equation |
| 2157 (pt) |
ais523 |
Any player may terminate the above-quoted pledge by announcement. |
FALSE |
| 2156 (pt) |
ais523 |
Sgeo may terminate the above-quoted pledge by announcement. |
FALSE |
| 2155 (pt) |
Ivan Hope |
The Speaker for the current game of Agora shall be Michael Norrish. |
FALSE |
| 2154 (pt) |
Ivan Hope |
The Speaker for the first game shall be Michael Norrish. |
TRUE |
| 2153 (pt) |
comex |
Randy Pausch is a person. |
FALSE |
| 2152 (pt) |
Goethe |
pikhq violated rule 2019 by failing to assign prerogatives for August 2008 in a timely fashion before August 1. |
GUILTY |
| 2151 (pt) |
Ivan Hope |
A moment ago, I revealed that my age is a composite number by announcement. |
TRUE |
| 2150 (pt) |
Ivan Hope |
A moment ago, I landed on the moon by announcement. |
case open |
| 2149 (pt) |
Ivan Hope |
A moment ago, I celebrated by announcement. |
TRUE |
| 2148 (pt) |
comex |
tusho has violated section 15 of the AAA agreement. |
case open |
| 2147 (pt) |
ais523 |
This CFH has ID number 1. |
FALSE |
| 2146 (pt) |
ais523 |
This CFJ has ID number 2146. |
TRUE |
| 2145 (pt) |
ehird |
People will thank me for this fifth CFJ. |
UNDETERMINED |
| 2144 (pt) |
ehird |
People will thank me for this fourth CFJ. |
UNDETERMINED |
| 2143 (pt) |
ehird |
People will thank me for this third CFJ. |
UNDETERMINED |
| 2142 (pt) |
ehird |
People will thank me for this second CFJ. |
UNDETERMINED |
| 2141 (pt) |
ehird |
People will thank me for this first CFJ. |
UNDETERMINED |
| 2140 (pt) |
Ivan Hope |
The rulesets of Agoroo A and Agoroo B are separate nomic rulesets. |
TRUE |
| 2139 (pt) |
Ivan Hope |
Agoroo A and Agoroo B are separate nomics. |
TRUE |
| 2138 (pt) |
Murphy |
If a partner acts on behalf of a partnership to transfer an asset, it is still the partner's asset that is transferred (provided that e has such an asset, and that the transfer is otherwise POSSIBLE). |
FALSE |
| 2137 (pt) |
Murphy |
If a partner acts on behalf of a partnership to cast a vote, that vote is still cast by that partner, and is thus subject to that partner's voting limit. |
FALSE |
| 2136 (pt) |
comex |
CFJ 2050 was filed by ehird |
TRUE |
| 2135 (pt) |
Quazie |
Quazie's activity switch was flipped to inactive by the above message. |
FALSE |
| 2134 (pt) |
cdm014 |
Gender Neutral pronouns(e.g eir, e, and e's) are words granted meaning and usage under the set of rules excluding 754(4). |
UNDETERMINED |
| 2133 (pt) |
ehird |
"<Speech act>. The previous sentence is false." results in <speech act> being performed. |
FALSE |
| 2132 (pt) |
ehird |
I am sitting. |
FALSE |
| 2131 (pt) |
ehird |
I am a player. |
TRUE |
| 2130 (pt) |
ehird |
tusho is a player. |
TRUE |
| 2129 (pt) |
ehird |
A player can be nominated to be Rulekeepor. |
TRUE |
| 2128 (pt) |
Sgeo |
I violated Rule 2149 by claiming that I lie when I did not, in fact lie. |
UNDETERMINED |
| 2127 (pt) |
Wooble |
The devolution of the AFO's obligations onto comex means that the AFO is in breach of the AAA agreement if comex calls CFJs for the clear purpose of allowing the CFJ to harvest their ID numbers. |
FALSE |
| 2126 (pt) |
comex |
I need more Water Rights Vouchers! |
IRRELEVANT |
| 2125 (pt) |
comex |
I need more Water Rights Vouchers! |
IRRELEVANT |
| 2124 (pt) |
comex |
I need more Water Rights Vouchers! |
IRRELEVANT |
| 2123 (pt) |
comex |
I need more Water Rights Vouchers! |
IRRELEVANT |
| 2122 (pt) |
comex |
I need more Water Rights Vouchers! |
IRRELEVANT |
| 2121 (pt) |
Goethe |
The Speaker CAN assign prerogatives for September 2008. |
FALSE |
| 2120 (pt) |
Goethe |
The Speaker CAN assign prerogatives for August 2008. |
TRUE |
| 2119 (pt) |
ehird |
ihope has not ascended the game and is not performing the action of ascending the game at this moment. |
case open |
| 2118 (pt) |
Wooble |
A judicial finding has determined that X, for the purposes of R2125 and R2161, if and only if a CFJ directly inquiring into the veracity of either X or not X has a judgment of TRUE or FALSE respectively. |
FALSE |
| 2117 (pt) |
Ivan Hope |
Posting the string [ed: moved to evidence due to length] to a Public Forum would be Monstrous Consent. |
TRUE |
| 2116 (pt) |
Wooble |
The contract quoted above currently has Ivan Hope CXXVII as a party. |
UNDETERMINED |
| 2115 (pt) |
Ivan Hope |
Immediately after a judge is assigned to this case, it will be legal for that judge to judge FALSE on its question on veracity. |
UNDECIDABLE |
| 2114 (pt) |
Quazie |
If an entity is not elgible to own a particular type of asset, then they own zero of that asset |
TRUE |
| 2113 (pt) |
Wooble |
Sgeo violated Rule 1742 by leaving the contract "The Winning Team" when the contract forbid leaving the contract. |
INNOCENT |
| 2112 (pt) |
comex |
Publishing the message "I object", in response to an attempt to perform a dependent action, causes an action to be taken by announcement. |
FALSE |
| 2111 (pt) |
ehird |
tusho violated rule 2149 by stating that the initiation of this CFJ will fail. |
UNIMPUGNED |
| 2110 (pt) |
Murphy |
At least two of the valid votes on Proposal 5648 were cast by the same player. |
FALSE |
| 2109 (pt) |
OscarMeyr |
A non-player can violate a rule of Agora. |
TRUE |
| 2108 (pt) |
BobTHJ |
Ivan Hope has failed to increase eir VP holdings above 50 within the allotted 60 day timeframe. |
equation |
| 2107 (pt) |
Goethe |
Ivan Hope violated R2149 by making the untruthful statement "UNDECIDABLE is never appropriate." |
GUILTY |
| 2106 (pt) |
Ivan Hope |
Goethe violated rule 2158 by judging UNDECIDABLE on CFJ 2087. |
ALREADY TRIED |
| 2105 (pt) |
Ivan Hope |
Goethe violated rule 2158 by judging UNDECIDABLE on CFJ 2086. |
GUILTY |
| 2104 (pt) |
Goethe |
ihope changed eir Registrar-recorded nickname to avpx on or about Jul 19th. |
FALSE |
| 2103 (pt) |
Sgeo |
I violated Rule 2149 by claiming that I lie when I did not, in fact lie. |
INNOCENT |
| 2102 (pt) |
comex |
OscarMeyr violated Rule 2149 by claiming that tusho could not have violated any rules because e was not a player. |
SLIPPERY |
| 2101 (pt) |
Sgeo |
Equity case judgements violate R101(iv). |
FALSE |
| 2100 (pt) |
Wooble |
upon Ivan Hope transferring to em all eir VPs, Sgeo did not, as soon as possible, transfer all eir VPs to Ivan Hope. |
equation |
| 2099 (pt) |
Pavitra |
I transfer all my crops to the PNP. |
FALSE |
| 2098 (pt) |
ais523 |
No matter what their contents, all public messages contain at least one game-relevant action |
FALSE |
| 2097 (pt) |
Quazie |
The Executor of a message that contains a CFJ is also the Initiator of that CFJ, even if the Executor says E submits the CFJ on behalf of someone/something else |
FALSE |
| 2096 (pt) |
root |
There is an inquiry case with the ID number 2073. |
TRUE |
| 2095 (pt) |
Goethe |
The statement labeled by the CotC as the CFJ statement for CFJ 2080 was a CFJ statement called by Quazie. |
UNDETERMINED |
| 2094 (pt) |
Goethe |
The statement labeled by the CotC as the CFJ statement for CFJ 2079 was a CFJ statement called by root. |
UNDETERMINED |
| 2093 (pt) |
Murphy |
Human Point Two bears the patent title Minister Without Portfolio |
FALSE |
| 2092 (pt) |
ehird |
tusho violated rule 101 by abridging, reducing, limiting, or removing Blind, Deaf and Mute's rights. |
INNOCENT |
| 2091 (pt) |
ehird |
Quazie violated rule 101 by abridging, reducing, limiting, or removing Blind, Deaf and Mute's rights. |
INNOCENT |
| 2090 (pt) |
Quazie |
CFJ 2019 is a valid CFJ. |
TRUE |
| 2089 (pt) |
woggle |
The PerlNomic Partnership transferred 150 chits to woggle as a result of the quoted message. |
TRUE |
| 2088 (pt) |
Wooble |
tusho violated Rule 2029 by changing eir posture to sitting. |
INNOCENT |
| 2087 (pt) |
ehird |
I CFJ on the following statement. |
TRUE |
| 2086 (pt) |
ehird |
I CFJ on the previous statement. |
FALSE |
| 2085 (pt) |
comex |
comex breached rule 2149 by thinking up statements that will be public although they are not true before e has sent them |
UNIMPUGNED |
| 2084 (pt) |
comex |
comex breached rule 2149 by sending a message with message-id <6bf32280807151511sfca8f7dveb137ee7d95c576 @mail.gmail.com> in which e did not tell the truth (because e did not say anything) |
SLIPPERY |
| 2083 (pt) |
comex |
root breached rule 2149 by claiming that the precedent from CFJ 1738 is that speech acts carry truth values |
INNOCENT |
| 2082 (pt) |
comex |
ehird breached rule 2149 by claiming to kill Goethe in eir message with message-id <784a579e0807151341l7123d535wdfcc5376130d2cb2 @mail.gmail.com> |
GUILTY |
| 2081 (pt) |
comex |
Goethe breached rule 2149 by claiming to dance in eir message with message-id <Pine.LNX.4.43.0807151338310.13451 @hymn11.u.washington.edu> |
INNOCENT |
| 2080 (pt) |
Quazie |
I CFJ on this statement. |
TRUE |
| 2079 (pt) |
root |
I CFJ on this statement. |
TRUE |
| 2078 (pt) |
Wooble |
Two contracts CAN have the same name. |
FALSE |
| 2077 (pt) |
Ivan Hope |
Ivan Hope is a player |
FALSE |
| 2076 (pt) |
ehird |
tusho has 24 VP. |
FALSE |
| 2075 (pt) |
ehird |
ehird is a player. |
FALSE |
| 2074 (pt) |
ehird |
tusho is a player. |
FALSE |
| 2073 (pt) |
Ivan Hope |
Either the sky is always red or, if I do not hereby initiate an inquiry case on this sentence, then the sky is always green. |
TRUE |
| 2072 (pt) |
BobTHJ |
the CotC (Murphy) violated R2019 by not assigning the Default Justice (myself) to be member of this appeals panel. |
UNAWARE |
| 2071 (pt) |
comex |
If there had been no disclaimer in the message sent by comex with Message-ID <6bf32280807111120s54788104x1e5e3a3001cb1be5 @mail.gmail.com>, and Rule 2208 did not exist, comex would have taken at least one action besides submitting a CFJ by sending it. |
TRUE |
| 2070 (pt) |
comex |
If there had been no disclaimer in the message sent by comex with Message-ID <6bf32280807111120s54788104x1e5e3a3001cb1be5 @mail.gmail.com>, comex would have taken at least one action besides submitting a CFJ by sending it. |
TRUE |
| 2069 (pt) |
Goethe |
There are no game-relevant actions or intents of action in the message sent by comex with Message-ID: <6bf32280807111120s54788104x1e5e3a3001cb1be5 @mail.gmail.com> |
FALSE |
| 2068 (pt) |
Sgeo |
Sgeo is obligated to give Ivan Hope CXXVII an amount of VP |
TRUE |
| 2067 (pt) |
Ivan Hope |
Sgeo could stash all the currency I didn't give him, then claim he only has to give back what he has after stashing. This is clearly a great injustice. |
equation |
| 2066 (pt) |
Goethe |
Goethe won by extortion on or about July 7, 2008. |
FALSE |
| 2065 (pt) |
ehird |
Sgeo has won today or yesterday (relative to the initiation of this CFJ). |
FALSE |
| 2064 (pt) |
ais523 |
The message quoted in the evidence section of this CFJ changed the text of a public contract |
FALSE |
| 2062 (pt) |
Ivan Hope |
The contract Ivan Hope just agreed to is a pledge because it states "Guvf vf n cyrqtr.", which is "This is a pledge." in rot13. |
TRUE |
| 2061 (pt) |
root |
The Reformed Bank of Agora is a partnership. |
TRUE |
| 2060 (pt) |
Sgeo |
The CotC MAY NOT refuse cases based on cases being excess as defined by Rule 2175 |
FALSE |
| 2059 (pt) |
Goethe |
BobTHJ holds the Patent Title Left in a Huff. |
FALSE |
| 2058 (pt) |
ais523 |
If an officer attempts to post a self-ratifying report to a public forum, but it does not arrive until over a week after it left the officer's technical domain of control, the report nonetheless self-ratifies even though none of the other players are aware of what its contents are. |
TRUE |
| 2057 (pt) |
Murphy |
ehrid is a player. |
TRUE |
| 2056 (pt) |
Taral |
A message containing one action sent to multiple fora is still only one action. |
TRUE |
| 2055 (pt) |
Wooble |
ais523 was a person on Agora's birthday. |
TRUE |
| 2054 (pt) |
ais523 |
ais523 has a Magenta Ribbon |
FALSE |
| 2053 (pt) |
ehird |
ehird violated rule 2149 by lying. |
ALREADY TRIED |
| 2052 (pt) |
BobTHJ |
OscarMeyr has explicitly refused to join the Agoran Slavery pledge, and the other players have implicitly refused to do so by their inaction. |
equation |
| 2051 (pt) |
BobTHJ |
ais523 can fill the Buy Ticket specified in the evidence more than once. |
FALSE |
| 2050 (pt) |
ehird |
This CFJ was filed by ehird |
FALSE |
| 2049 (pt) |
ehird |
This CFJ exists. |
TRUE |
| 2048 (pt) |
comex |
ehird violated Rule 2149 by saying that e joins. |
GUILTY |
| 2047 (pt) |
ehird |
notehird is a registered player. |
FALSE |
| 2046 (pt) |
ehird |
ehrid devolves its obligations onto at least two people. |
TRUE |
| 2045 (pt) |
Quazie |
Comex objected to the termination of the pledge which allows anything to act on behalf of ehird. |
TRUE |
| 2044 (pt) |
ais523 |
comex violated rule 2185 by failing to assign a judgement to an open and applicable judicial question of CFJ 2006 as soon as possible. |
UNIMPUGNED |
| 2043 (pt) |
ais523 |
comex violated rule 2185 by failing to assign a judgement to an open and applicable judicial question of CFJ 1996 as soon as possible. |
UNIMPUGNED |
| 2042 (pt) |
Goethe |
If a partnership dissolves after having incurred obligations from another contract, the former members may be required by an equity settlement involving the second contract to be a parties to the settlement. |
TRUE |
| 2041 (pt) |
Goethe |
If a partnership incurs contract obligations from another contract while a particular member is a member, and that member departs the partnership, the member in question may be required by an equity settlement involving the second contract to be a party to the settlement, even if the partnership agreement does not explicitly allow this. |
TRUE |
| 2040 (pt) |
Goethe |
If a partnership is party to another contract, individual members of the contract may be required, by an equity settlement involving the second contract, to be parties to the settlement, even if the partnership agreement does not explicitly allow this. |
TRUE |
| 2039 (pt) |
Quazie |
The Judgement of CFJ 2029 indicates that BobTHJ is in violation of point 12 of the AAA contract by not creating a mill in the possession of Quazie after revoking 3 points from em. |
equation |
| 2038 (pt) |
BobTHJ |
Due to eir deregistration ehird has not acted in the manner envisioned by section 11 of the contract. |
equation |
| 2037 (pt) |
BobTHJ |
ehird violated R1742 by not acting in accordance with section 11 of the Protection Racket agreement when he posted a pledge allowing anyone to act on eir behalf. |
INNOCENT |
| 2036 (pt) |
comex |
Murphy took all of the AFO's assets. |
equation |
| 2035 (pt) |
Goethe |
If the previous CFJ is found TRUE, its judge CAN and SHOULD award comex the Patent Title Scamster by announcement. |
FALSE |
| 2034 (pt) |
Goethe |
comex has shown great enthusiasm, persistence, or skill in the perpetrating of scams. |
TRUE |
| 2033 (pt) |
Quazie |
The Agoran Agricultural Association is a contest |
TRUE |
| 2032 (pt) |
comex |
The hypothetical contract in the evidence section, if made a contest, would be effective, because neither Rule 101 (vi.) nor Rule 478 would prevent its operation. |
FALSE |
| 2031 (pt) |
ais523 |
ehird violated rule 2149 by knowingly or recklessly making a false statement. |
UNIMPUGNED |
| 2030 (pt) |
woggle |
It is possible for ehird to cause woggle to vote by announcing 'On behalf of woggle: woggle retracts eir votes on proposal 5568 and votes AGAINST x 6 on proposal 5568'. |
FALSE |
| 2029 (pt) |
Quazie |
As a result of removing 3 points from Quazie on Jun 17, 2008 at 12:00 PM BobTHJ must create a mill, other than land #98, in Quazie's possession or BobTHJ is in violation of the AAA contract |
TRUE |
| 2028 (pt) |
root |
the Reformed Bank of Agora violated R2144 by registering while having the same basis (BobTHJ and Ivan Hope CXXVII) as the Protection Racket, a registered player. |
GUILTY |
| 2027 (pt) |
Ivan Hope |
The Notary is the recordkeepor of public contracts. |
OVERRULE / TRUE |
| 2026 (pt) |
root |
The Left Hand is a public contract. |
TRUE |
| 2025 (pt) |
ehird |
comex violated rule 2149 by lying in the quoted message. |
SLIPPERY |
| 2024 (pt) |
ehird |
comex deregistered sometime around or on Thursday, June 19th, 2008 at 8:06:36pm MDT. |
FALSE |
| 2023 (pt) |
ais523 |
root broke rule 1742 by failing to act in accordance with the Brainfuck Golf contract. |
INNOCENT |
| 2022 (pt) |
Murphy |
comex violated Rule 1504 by failing to publish an apology for CFJ 1942. |
GUILTY |
| 2021 (pt) |
ais523 |
If an entity is both a public message and a forum, it is necessarily a public forum. |
FALSE |
| 2020 (pt) |
Ivan Hope |
BobTHJ violated Rule 2158 by judging CFJ 2005 UNDECIDABLE. |
GUILTY |
| 2017 (pt) |
ehird |
I am a first-class partnership. |
FALSE |
| 2016 (pt) |
Zefram |
Quazie violated rule 2149 by publicly claiming in message <aa8936fe0806161718q6d3862fbl2e343709396fca5f @mail.gmail.com> that Echidna and Typhon are coauthors (or a coauthor) of the proposal that e submitted in that message. |
UNIMPUGNED |
| 2015 (pt) |
Quazie |
BobTHJ successfully created land #98 in Quazie's possession On or about Tue, Jun 17, 2008 at 12:59 PM. |
TRUE |
| 2014 (pt) |
Quazie |
If ehrid was able to act on my behalf at the time CFJ 1999 and CFJ 2000 were called one or more of the set of {CFJ 1999, CFJ 2000} would've been TRUE. |
FALSE |
| 2013 (pt) |
Ivan Hope |
Rule 2141 implies that a rule can destroy the universe. |
FALSE |
| 2012 (pt) |
BobTHJ |
comex breached Rule 1742 by continued failure to comply with the terms of the binding Equation of CFJ 1915 |
GUILTY |
| 2011 (pt) |
BobTHJ |
comex breached Rule 1742 by continued failure to comply with the terms of the binding Vote Market contract. |
GUILTY |
| 2010 (pt) |
ais523 |
OscarMeyr violated rule 2149 by claiming there was "nothing to see here" when in fact there was. |
UNIMPUGNED |
| 2009 (pt) |
Ivan Hope |
Ivan Hope violated rule 1742 by initiating this CFJ. |
UNIMPUGNED |
| 2008 (pt) |
Wooble |
Ehird deregistered on June 13, 2008, at or around 19:31 UTC |
FALSE |
| 2007 (pt) |
root |
Ivan Hope CXXVII is in the chokey. |
FALSE |
| 2006 (pt) |
avpx |
ehird's vote in the Assessor election is valid. |
FALSE |
| 2005 (pt) |
ehird |
Schrodinger's Cat is a player. |
OVERRULE / TRUE |
| 2004 (pt) |
Murphy |
Ivan Hope breached Rule 2149 (Truthfulness) by saying "By the way, did I mention I didn't have 50 pens in the first place, so you just gave me free stuff?" while believing e did have at least 50 pens at the time (on or about Mon, 09 Jun 2008 13:11:46 -0400) e claimed to transfer 50 pens to comex. |
UNIMPUGNED |
| 2003 (pt) |
comex |
Senator Hillary Rodham Clinton breached rule 101 by failing to treat Agora right good forever |
SLIPPERY |
| 2002 (pt) |
Pavitra |
Rule 2193 is at least one of: (1) a Monster; (2) the Monster. |
TRUE |
| 2001 (pt) |
Ivan Hope |
Murphy violated rule 1871 by rotating the bench while the Pineapple Partnership is qualified to judge. |
INNOCENT |
| 2000 (pt) |
Quazie |
ehird was deregistered when ehrid posted the following message: "I perform the following action on behalf of Quazie: {I deregister.}" |
FALSE |
| 1999 (pt) |
Quazie |
Quazie was deregistered when ehrid posted the following message: "I perform the following action on behalf of Quazie: {I deregister.}" |
FALSE |
| 1998 (pt) |
Quazie |
No change will occur to the OBJECTIONABLE contract based on comex's statement: 'Without 3 OBJECTIONS (I don't have any, for that matter), I hereby amend the OBJECTIONABLE contract to read: {{ 1. Any person can join this contract by announcement. 2. Any person other than Quazie can leave this contract by announcement. 3. Any person other than Quazie can perform any action on behalf of Quazie by announcement. }}' regardless of the number of objections that occur |
TRUE |
| 1997 (pt) |
Quazie |
The following two statements have different meanings, 1 - Without 3 OBJECTIONS, I hereby amend the OBJECTIONABLE contract to read: {{ 1. Any person can join this contract by announcement. 2. Any person other than Quazie can leave this contract by announcement. 3. Any person other than Quazie can perform any action on behalf of Quazie by announcement. }} 2 - Without 3 objections , I hereby amend the OBJECTIONABLE contract to read: {{ 1. Any person can join this contract by announcement. 2. Any person other than Quazie can leave this contract by announcement. 3. Any person other than Quazie can perform any action on behalf of Quazie by announcement. }} |
TRUE |
| 1996 (pt) |
Murphy |
On or about Mon, 09 Jun 2008 15:03:27 -0400, comex gave Ivan Hope 50 pens |
TRUE |
| 1995 (pt) |
Murphy |
Ivan Hope breached Rule 2149 (Truthfulness) by claiming (on or about Mon, 09 Jun 2008 13:11:46 -0400) to give comex 50 pens. |
INNOCENT |
| 1994 (pt) |
ais523 |
The PerlNomic Partnership has voted FOR on the Agoran decision on whether to adopt proposal 5545. |
TRUE |
| 1993 (pt) |
ais523 |
Murphy breached rule 2158 by failing to recuse the judicial panel of comex, Pavitra and pikhq with cause. |
GUILTY |
| 1992 (pt) |
Quazie |
It is an entity, where the aforementioned 'it' is any thing. |
TRUE |
| 1991 (pt) |
ais523 |
ehird has apologised as required by the judgement of the question on sentencing of CFJ 1943. |
TRUE |
| 1990 (pt) |
root |
The CotC CAN assign a poorly qualified player to judge a case. |
TRUE |
| 1989 (pt) |
root |
All actions are regulated. |
FALSE |
| 1988 (pt) |
Ivan Hope |
It's an entity. |
UNDETERMINED |
| 1987 (pt) |
Ivan Hope |
The Lost and Found Department owns the oddball {2/3,3/4} |
TRUE |
| 1986 (pt) |
Ivan Hope |
Ivan Hope CXXVII owns the oddball {2/3,3/4} |
FALSE |
| 1985 (pt) |
comex |
The first paragraph of Rule 1586 has no effect. |
FALSE |
| 1984 (pt) |
comex |
At least one of the following statements is true: - War is Peace. - Freedom is Slavery. - Ignorance is Strength. |
IRRELEVANT |
| 1983 (pt) |
ais523 |
There is a CFJ with ID number 1934 |
TRUE |
| 1982 (pt) |
ehird |
comex CAN initiate an equity case concerning the Gnarlier Contract |
UNDECIDABLE |
| 1981 (pt) |
comex |
If I am judged GUILTY in CFJ 1935, a sentence other than DISCHARGE is appropriate |
TRUE |
| 1980 (pt) |
ais523 |
comex CAN initiate an equity case concerning the Gnarlier Contract |
UNDECIDABLE |
| 1979 (pt) |
woggle |
When CFJ 1972 was called, it was possible for Pavitra to make Kiwi into a contest without 3 objections. |
FALSE |
| 1978 (pt) |
woggle |
Wooble has a Cyan ribbon. |
FALSE |
| 1977 (pt) |
Pavitra |
If a player announces "I pledge {this is the Pear contract}; the following sentence has no effect. I pledge {this is the Papaya contract}; the preceding sentence has no effect.", and no attempt is made to dissolve the Pear contract, then another player CAN join the Pear contract by announcement. |
FALSE |
| 1976 (pt) |
ehird |
ais523 could, at the time this CFJ was called, leave The Gnarly Contract by announcement |
OVERRULE / FALSE |
| 1975 (pt) |
ais523 |
ais523 could, at the time this CFJ was called, leave The Gnarly Contract by announcement |
OVERRULE / FALSE |
| 1974 (pt) |
comex |
When CFJ 1972 was called, it was possible for Pavrita to leave Kiwi. |
FALSE |
| 1973 (pt) |
Pavitra |
Pavitra is a party to Kiwi. |
OVERRULE / FALSE |
| 1972 (pt) |
Pavitra |
Pavitra is a party to Mango. |
OVERRULE / FALSE |
| 1971 (pt) |
ais523 |
It is possible to take a game action even in a message which includes the disclaimer in the evidence section. |
TRUE |
| 1970 (pt) |
ehird |
"A few CFJs" accurately describes the amount of CFJs I have recently called. |
IRRELEVANT |
| 1969 (pt) |
ehird |
"A few CFJs" accurately describes the amount of CFJs I have recently called. |
IRRELEVANT |
| 1968 (pt) |
ehird |
"A few CFJs" accurately describes the amount of CFJs I have recently called. |
IRRELEVANT |
| 1967 (pt) |
ehird |
"A few CFJs" accurately describes the amount of CFJs I have recently called. |
IRRELEVANT |
| 1966 (pt) |
comex |
R101 item i. reads: i. The map being obviously the most important rule, every person has the right to move it back up to the top of the ruleset if the Rulekeepor put it down near the bottom again. |
FALSE |
| 1965 (pt) |
ais523 |
ehird's Announcement of Chaos caused at least one contract to terminate. |
FALSE |
| 1964 (pt) |
Ivan Hope |
Ivan Hope violated rule 2149 by making a public statement that two plus two is five. |
UNIMPUGNED |
| 1963 (pt) |
ehird |
Ivan Hope violated Rule 2173 by revealing the text of that private contract. |
INNOCENT |
| 1962 (pt) |
ais523 |
In the quoted message, ehird sent an infinite number of messages. |
FALSE |
| 1961 (pt) |
Goethe |
Proposal A is distributed and is filibustered (and remains filibustered) during emergency session; given no rule changes, a week and a day later, a vote cast on it may be valid. |
TRUE |
| 1960 (pt) |
ais523 |
If a player's voting limit on an Agoran decision reduces during that decision's voting period, then all votes that that player has already cast on that decision are no longer valid. |
FALSE |
| 1959 (pt) |
ais523 |
If a player's voting limit on an Agoran decision reduces during that decision's voting period, then all votes that that player has already cast on that decision are still valid. |
FALSE |
| 1958 (pt) |
Murphy |
There exists at least one rule with Power = 1. |
TRUE |
| 1957 (pt) |
Ivan Hope |
There is a pen that owns at least 1 crumpet. |
FALSE |
| 1956 (pt) |
Ivan Hope |
There is a pen that owns at least 5 crumpets. |
FALSE |
| 1955 (pt) |
comex |
If Rule 101 gives me the right to perform an action in this game, but the Rules do not define a mechanism for performing that action, I can perform it by announcement. |
FALSE |
| 1954 (pt) |
ehird |
In the message archived at the URL <http://www.agoranomic.org/cgi-bin/mailman/private/ agora-business/2008-May/010573.html>, ehird won the game. |
FALSE |
| 1953 (pt) |
Goethe |
A individual player may be found GUILTY in a criminal case for an action performed by a judicial panel of which e is a member, if the judicial panel performs the action as described in R2157. |
FALSE |
| 1952 (pt) |
Goethe |
comex violated Rule 101(vii) and Goethe's defined rights by initiating a criminal case against Goethe, when Goethe is already being punished for the same single action (by having to defend emself in a separate, previously-initiated criminal case). |
UNIMPUGNED |
| 1951 (pt) |
comex |
Goethe violated Rule 217 by submitting a judgement (on behalf of an appeal panel) for the appeal case CFJ 1932a. |
UNIMPUGNED |
| 1950 (pt) |
root |
Wooble breached Rule 2157 by failing to ensure that the panel met all of its obligations in appeal case 1932a. Specifically, the panel failed to meet its obligation to assign an appropriate judgement in that case. |
INNOCENT |
| 1949 (pt) |
root |
Murphy breached Rule 2157 by failing to ensure that the panel met all of its obligations in appeal case 1932a. Specifically, the panel failed to meet its obligation to assign an appropriate judgement in that case. |
INNOCENT |
| 1948 (pt) |
root |
Goethe breached Rule 2157 by failing to ensure that the panel met all of its obligations in appeal case 1932a. Specifically, the panel failed to meet its obligation to assign an appropriate judgement in that case. |
INNOCENT |
| 1947 (pt) |
Goethe |
If an appealed equity case judgement is REMANDED or REASSIGNED, the original (prior) judgement remains a binding agreement. |
FALSE |
| 1946 (pt) |
ais523 |
In the message found at <http://www.agoranomic.org/cgi-bin/mailman/private/ agora-business/2008-May/010509.html>, ihope agreed to something. |
FALSE |
| 1945 (pt) |
ehird |
Wooble violated Rule 101 by alienating new players by insulting eir religion. |
INNOCENT |
| 1944 (pt) |
Blaise Pascal |
If I were to post to a public forum any of the following statements, I would be a player: 1. I am a player. 2. I declare myself to be a player. |
FALSE |
| 1943 (pt) |
Wooble |
ehird breached Rule 1742 by not acting in accordance with eir obligations under the Ducks & Platypuses agreement, by being a party to that agreement. |
GUILTY |
| 1942 (pt) |
Wooble |
comex breached Rule 1742 by not acting in accordance with eir obligations under the Ducks & Platypuses agreement, by being a party to that agreement. |
GUILTY |
| 1941 (pt) |
Ivan Hope |
A contract can allow arbitrary persons to act on behalf of its parties. |
TRUE |
| 1940 (pt) |
Ivan Hope |
Ivan Hope violated Rule 1742 by not transferring one pen to Murphy as soon as possible after making this pledge. |
GUILTY |
| 1939 (pt) |
ais523 |
If a rule states that an action is regulated, that does not prevent that action from taking place, but only prevents that thing from taking place under rule 101(ii) (and therefore makes it impossible to take that action unless another rule makes it possible). |
FALSE |
| 1938 (pt) |
Wooble |
ais523 violated Rule 2158 by assigning an inappropriate judgement to CFJ 1932. |
INNOCENT |
| 1937 (pt) |
woggle |
root is the contestmaster of the equation of CFJ1932. |
FALSE |
| 1936 (pt) |
Wooble |
The judge in an equity case CAN make the equation a contest by stating it is one. |
FALSE |
| 1935 (pt) |
Wooble |
comex violated Rule 1742 by failing to act in accordance with eir obligations under the CFJ 1915 equation. |
OVERLOOKED |
| 1934 (pt) |
ais523 |
Hello! |
IRRELEVANT |
| 1933 (pt) |
Goethe |
Due to the LAND GRAB pledge, Goethe is the recordkeeper for the types of crops currencies referenced by the Agoran Agricultural Association contract. |
FALSE |
| 1932 (pt) |
root |
I haven't left the contract at my first opportunity, as is expected of me. |
equation |
| 1931 (pt) |
comex |
IRCNomic is a public contract. |
FALSE |
| 1930 (pt) |
ais523 |
It is impossible for a player to become Referee within the meaning of the public contract that is the backing document for XP without failing to do something that its paragraph 8 specifies that the Referee SHALL do in that situation, under the current set of rules. |
TRUE |
| 1929 (pt) |
comex |
comex breached Rule 1742 by claiming that contract R requires that we "*pretend*" that it's a rule, which is not treating it like a rule, but rather a pretend rule, thereby violating its terms |
INNOCENT |
| 1927 (pt) |
BobTHJ |
comex has failed to submit Sell Tickets as required by section 2 of this Equation. The other parties have failed to suggest suitable tickets as required in section 3 of the equation. |
equation |
| 1926 (pt) |
Goethe |
If a pledge contains no explicit exit clause, a party may leave it by announcement. |
FALSE |
| 1925 (pt) |
woggle |
In eir report, the Notary is required to list Agora's Child as a member of the set of parties to a public contract concerning Trouts and Jester's Caps. |
FALSE |
| 1924 (pt) |
comex |
The message in the evidence section (1) would be invalid because "30 days, or until e updates the player list..." is not a valid duration (ignoring any other problems with the message) |
FALSE |
| 1923 (pt) |
Murphy |
pikhq has a bean. |
FALSE |
| 1922 (pt) |
Murphy |
Murphy has at least one bean. |
FALSE |
| 1921 (pt) |
Goethe |
If I publish the following statement 'I'll give a quatloo to you, comex, if you give me a dingbat', and quatloos and dingbats are Agoran quantities, and comex publishes 'Okay' in reference to the statement, it forms a binding agreement (a contract). |
TRUE |
| 1920 (pt) |
comex |
If the offer in the evidence section (1) were published by me, then accepted, any person would be able to become a party to the resultant contract by announcement. |
FALSE |
| 1919 (pt) |
Iammars |
pikhq breached Rule 2135 by neglecting his duty to update the Nomic Wiki page in the month of February. |
GUILTY |
| 1918 (pt) |
Iammars |
pikhq breached Rule 2135 by misrepresenting Agora on the Nomic Wiki by failing to include my name in the players list. |
GUILTY |
| 1917 (pt) |
Ivan Hope |
Goethe violated rule 2143 by not publishing a Notary report last month. |
GUILTY |
| 1916 (pt) |
comex |
In the quoted message, Iammars consented to something. |
FALSE |
| 1915 (pt) |
BobTHJ |
comex has breached the Vote Market agreement by failing to restore his VP to a level at or above 50 within 60 days of when it first fell below that threshold. |
equation |
| 1914 (pt) |
comex |
Rule 2166 exists. |
TRUE |
| 1913 (pt) |
comex |
Bob is a first-class person. |
FALSE |
| 1912 (pt) |
comex |
Bob is a player. |
FALSE |
| 1911 (pt) |
comex |
Bob is a person. |
FALSE |
| 1910 (pt) |
root |
One or more partnerships exist. |
TRUE |
| 1909 (pt) |
woggle |
CFJ 1903a has been judged. |
FALSE |
| 1908 (pt) |
woggle |
A concurring opinion has been published by the judicial panel in CFJ 1903a. |
FALSE |
| 1907 (pt) |
comex |
pikhq violated Rule 208 by failing to resolve eir intent to appeal CFJ 1856. |
GUILTY |
| 1906 (pt) |
Zefram |
comex violated rule 2149 by claiming in message <6bf32280802080851i14c79ea9oa8fc2768a80bc7af @mail.gmail.com> that proposal 5419 passed while not believing that to be true. |
GUILTY |
| 1905 (pt) |
comex |
There is a Rule 9999. |
FALSE |
| 1904 (pt) |
pikhq |
comex violated Rule 2149/8, Truthfulness, by falsely claiming that there exists a rule 9999. |
INNOCENT |
| 1903 (pt) |
Pavitra |
The above question initiated an inquiry case. |
FALSE |
| 1902 (pt) |
Levi |
Making the public statement 'This statement is not true' would cause the person making that statement to violate Rule 2149. |
TRUE |
| 1901 (pt) |
comex |
Y is a contract. |
TRUE |
| 1900 (pt) |
Murphy |
Zefram CAN register. |
FALSE |
| 1899 (pt) |
Murphy |
BobTHJ CAN register. |
FALSE |
| 1898 (pt) |
Murphy |
Zefram is a player. |
TRUE |
| 1897 (pt) |
comex |
BobTHJ is a player |
OVERRULE / TRUE |
| 1896 (pt) |
comex |
There exists a R2160 'position' that is not an office |
OVERRULE / TRUE |
| 1895 (pt) |
comex |
BobTHJ is an R2160 'position' |
FALSE |
| 1894 (pt) |
Zefram |
an inquiry case CAN be initiated with a question taking the role of the statement to be inquired into |
TRUE |
| 1893 (pt) |
root |
comex successfully caused at least one player other than emself to cast a vote on Proposal 5419. |
FALSE |
| 1892 (pt) |
pikhq |
comex's non-binding agreement 'X' is a contract. |
FALSE |
| 1891 (pt) |
Goethe |
If the Speaker fails to assign prerogatives for the upcoming month in the seven days before the beginning of a month, e CAN assign prerogatives (for that month) after the month has begun. |
FALSE |
| 1890 (pt) |
Goethe |
The Speaker CAN assign prerogatives for the upcoming month in the seven days before the beginning of a month. |
FALSE |
| 1889 (pt) |
Wooble |
Zefram violated Rule 2149 in the above message by making the statement "I intend to deputise for BobTHJ to deregister em." while not reasonably believing it to be true. |
UNIMPUGNED |
| 1888 (pt) |
pikhq |
The above message was a public message. |
FALSE |
| 1887 (pt) |
Levi |
Making the public statement 'This statement is a lie' would cause the person making that statement to violate Rule 2149. |
TRUE |
| 1886 (pt) |
Murphy |
BobTHJ has not deregistered. |
equation |
| 1885 (pt) |
Taral |
Eris' votes of ROOT on Proposal 5412 were valid. |
TRUE |
| 1884 (pt) |
BobTHJ |
Where the above referenced decision on amending the Vote Market agreement able to be validly resolved as of the calling of this CFJ would pikhq's vote of OBJECT be valid? |
UNDECIDABLE |
| 1883 (pt) |
BobTHJ |
Where the above referenced decision on amending the Vote Market agreement able to be validly resolved as of the calling of this CFJ would Pavitra's vote of OBJECT be valid? |
UNDECIDABLE |
| 1882 (pt) |
comex |
watcher is a Player |
TRUE |
| 1881 (pt) |
pikhq |
rule 2029 requires Agorans to always Dance a Powerful Dance. |
FALSE |
| 1880 (pt) |
comex |
The Agoran Agricultural Association is a contract. |
TRUE |
| 1879 (pt) |
pikhq |
Canada is a nomic. |
FALSE |
| 1878 (pt) |
woggle |
It is possible to, by announcement, cease to be a party to a contract which has exactly 1 party and which is both a location and a pledge when the contract explicitly permits this. |
FALSE |
| 1877 (pt) |
woggle |
It is possible to cease to be a party to a location which has exactly 1 party by announcement when the text of the location explicitly permits this. |
FALSE |
| 1876 (pt) |
woggle |
It is possible to cease to be a party to a pledge which has exactly 1 party by announcement when the text of pledge explicitly permits this. |
FALSE |
| 1875 (pt) |
Levi |
Levi is The Speaker. |
FALSE |
| 1874 (pt) |
Levi |
Murphy is The Speaker. |
TRUE |
| 1873 (pt) |
Levi |
Human Point Two Bears the patent title Minister Without Portfolio. |
FALSE |
| 1872 (pt) |
pikhq |
The Vote Market is a contract. |
TRUE |
| 1871 (pt) |
Goethe |
If a judge makes the right judgement but for the wrong reasons, then e has made an inappropriate judgement. |
FALSE |
| 1870 (pt) |
Zefram |
where a prerogative has been assigned to a person for a particular month, and no assignment of prerogatives has yet been made for the following month, that person loses that prerogative at the end of that month |
TRUE |
| 1869 (pt) |
pikhq |
it is possible to join the Vote Market while already a member of the Vote Market. |
FALSE |
| 1868 (pt) |
BobTHJ |
woggle breached Rule 911 by assigning an inappropriate judgment to CFJ 1860a. |
INNOCENT |
| 1867 (pt) |
BobTHJ |
root breached Rule 911 by assigning an inappropriate judgment to CFJ 1860a. |
INNOCENT |
| 1866 (pt) |
BobTHJ |
Murphy breached Rule 911 by assigning an inappropriate judgment to CFJ 1860a. |
INNOCENT |
| 1865 (pt) |
Zefram |
the Patent Title of Champion CAN be awarded by announcement of the Herald to a person who has not won the game |
FALSE |
| 1864 (pt) |
root |
The Left Hand is a partnership. |
TRUE |
| 1863 (pt) |
Zefram |
BobTHJ violated rule 2158 by failing to assign an appropriate judgement to the question on veracity in CFJ 1860 when obliged to, by means of assigning an inappropriate judgement instead. |
EXCUSED |
| 1862 (pt) |
Murphy |
Human Point Two bears the Patent Title of Minister Without Portfolio. |
FALSE |
| 1861 (pt) |
Iammars |
Players may always be referred to by eir legal name along with eir nickname. |
FALSE |
| 1860 (pt) |
pikhq |
It is a violation of rule 2159 to falsely claim that something is a protective decree to Steve Wallace (the biological person, not necessarily the player). |
FALSE |
| 1859 (pt) |
comex |
At least one of the votes in root's message with message-id <3fc761710712310956p646fddd3h9ca3b5ceb0c16fe4 @mail.gmail.com> is valid. |
FALSE |
| 1858 (pt) |
woggle |
root violated rule 1769 by assigning, during a Holiday, judgement to the judicial question on culpability in CFJ 1838 in the above-quoted message. |
OVERRULE / GUILTY |
| 1857 (pt) |
woggle |
root violated rule 1769 by assigning, during a Holiday, judgement to the judicial question on culpability in CFJ 1837 in the above-quoted message. |
OVERRULE / GUILTY |
| 1856 (pt) |
Zefram |
Steve Wallace is a player |
FALSE |
| 1855 (pt) |
pikhq |
The AFO is not part of the basis of Agora's Child, but is a partner of Agora's Child. |
FALSE |
| 1854 (pt) |
avpx |
It is possible to spend VCs that one does not own. |
FALSE |
| 1853 (pt) |
Goethe |
comex has violated Rule 2149 in his communication of voting on proposal 5380. |
UNIMPUGNED |
| 1852 (pt) |
Goethe |
comex has violated Rule 2149 in his communication of voting on proposal 5375. |
UNIMPUGNED |
| 1851 (pt) |
Murphy |
Proposal 5373 was adopted in Message-ID: <476D30DB.6040804@socal.rr.com> |
TRUE |
| 1850 (pt) |
Murphy |
pikhq won in Message-Id: <200712202153.34050.josiahw@gmail.com> |
FALSE |
| 1849 (pt) |
Zefram |
BobTHJ violated rule 2149 by publishing in message <56732cfd0712210825i54c896f7n9f4795405528894e @mail.gmail.com> a statement that e did not believe was true. |
GUILTY |
| 1848 (pt) |
Murphy |
Futuremyartug is a player. |
FALSE |
| 1847 (pt) |
Zefram |
when a person calls for judgement, and has already done so at least five times in the same week, e is awarded one blue mark by section (+b) of rule 2176 |
FALSE |
| 1846 (pt) |
BobTHJ |
The sentence issued by BobTHJ (prior to appeal) in CFJ 1812 included a valid set of prescribed words. |
OVERRULE / TRUE |
| 1845 (pt) |
Murphy |
comex initiated two criminal cases in Message-Id: <200712181706.58039.comexk@gmail.com> |
FALSE |
| 1844 (pt) |
pikhq |
submitting a protective decree to Steve Wallace is a violation of rule 2159. |
TRUE |
| 1843 (pt) |
WALRUS |
It is possible for joining a contract to take effect retroactively. |
FALSE |
| 1842 (pt) |
WALRUS |
It is possible for a contract change to take effect retroactively. |
UNDETERMINED |
| 1841 (pt) |
WALRUS |
It is possible for a game action to take effect retroactively. |
TRUE |
| 1840 (pt) |
pikhq |
WALRUS is a player. |
FALSE |
| 1839 (pt) |
pikhq |
Zefram violated Rule 2149/8. ("A person SHALL NOT make a public statement unless e believes in doing so e is telling the truth.") In message <20071219230243.GL17928@fysh.org>, Zefram claimed that the attempt to register WALRUS was ineffective, since 'WALRUS does not adequately identify any particular entity'. |
INNOCENT |
| 1838 (pt) |
comex |
BobTHJ breached Rule 2149 by, as a knight, publishing a statement that e believed to be false in eir message with Message-ID <56732cfd0711041449h23dcc500id9e643c76643d597 @mail.gmail.com> |
INNOCENT |
| 1837 (pt) |
comex |
BobTHJ breached Rule 2149 by, as a knight, publishing a statement that e believed to be false in eir message with Message-ID <56732cfd0710291242h67fc331and43dd1076934828 @mail.gmail.com> |
INNOCENT |
| 1836 (pt) |
comex |
Fookiemyartug is a player. |
FALSE |
| 1835 (pt) |
comex |
In this message, comex submitted a CFJ on the statement "Who am I?" |
FALSE |
|